Understanding Above the Line vs Below the Line Leadership

Above the line vs below the line leadership, explore the difference banner

There are two main ways to lead: above the line and below the line. Below the line leadership is focused on survival, while above the line leadership is focused on growth. There are pros and cons to both styles of leadership, so it’s important to understand them before making a decision about which style to use. In this article, we’ll explore the difference between these two styles of leadership, and we’ll discuss the pros and cons of each one. We’ll also provide tips for using each style effectively. So if you’re looking to become a better leader, or if you’re just curious about different leadership styles, read on!

What is above the line leadership and what is below the line leadership?

Above the line leadership is about taking responsibility for your own actions and decisions. It’s about being accountable for your own performance and setting high standards for yourself and your team. Below the line leadership is about micromanaging and controlling every aspect of your team’s work. It’s about being punitive and demanding obedience. Above the line leadership is more effective because it builds trust and respect, while below the line leadership breeds fear and resentment. When you’re able to take responsibility for your own actions and decisions, people will trust you more. They’ll also be more likely to follow your lead when you’re clear about what you expect from them.

When you’re constantly demanding that people do things your way, they’ll start to resent you. And when they resent you, they’re less likely to listen to you or follow your lead. If you want to be an effective leader, focus on being above the line. Take responsibility for your own actions and decisions, and set high standards for yourself and your team. Your team will respect you more, and they’ll be more likely to follow your lead.

Key differences between above the line leadership and below the line leadership

There are several key differences between above the line leadership and below the line leadership:

  1. Above the line leadership generally focuses on long-term goals and objectives, while below the line leadership tends to focus on short-term results.
  2. Above the line leaders typically have a more strategic orientation, while below the line leaders tend to be more operational in their focus.
  3. Above the line leaders are typically more proactive, while below the line leaders are often more reactive.
  4. Above the line leaders are typically more inspirational, while below the line leaders often rely more on positional power.
Leader lecturing his employees in office
Leader lecturing his employees in office

Pros of above the line leadership over below the line leadership

There are several advantages of using an above the line leadership style over a below the line leadership style:

  1. Above the line leaders typically have a more positive outlook and are more proactive when it comes to problem solving.
  2. They also tend to be better at delegating tasks and responsibilities, and they are generally more open to new ideas.
  3. Above the line leaders are also typically more effective at communicating their vision and goals to their team members.

Below the line leadership styles can often result in a more negative work environment, as well as decreased productivity levels.

Cons of above the line leadership compared to below the line leadership

There are several disadvantages of above the line leadership compared to below the line leadership:

  1. Above the line leaders often have less interaction with their subordinates, which can lead to a disconnect between leader and follower.
  2. Above the line leadership can sometimes be viewed as autocratic and overly directive, which can foster resentment among employees.
  3. Because above the line leaders typically make decisions without input from subordinates, they may not be aware of potential problems or issues until it is too late to address them.

Pros of below the line leadership over above the line leadership

There are a few key advantages that below the line leadership has over above the line leadership

  1. One key advantage is that below the line leadership allows for more decentralized decision-making. This can lead to faster decision-making and implementation as decisions do not have to be filtered through a central authority figure.
  2. Below the line leadership often results in greater employee buy-in and engagement as employees feel more empowered and invested in the decisions being made.
  3. Below the line leadership can help build a more collaborative and cohesive team as everyone is working together towards a common goal.

Above the line leadership, on the other hand, can often be seen as dictatorial and autocratic, which can lead to resentment and resistance from employees.

Leader encourage his team
Leader encourage his team

Cons of below the line leadership compared to above the line leadership

There are several key disadvantages of below the line leadership compared to above the line leadership:

  1. Below the line leadership generally results in less engaged and motivated employees, as they may feel that their input is not valued or that their work is not fulfilling.
  2. Below the line leadership can lead to an increased sense of competition and conflict within an organization, as employees jockey for position and recognition.
  3. Below the line leadership often results in a more hierarchical organizational structure, with clear lines of authority and power. This can limit creativity and innovation, as employees are less likely to take risks when there are clear consequences for failure.

Situations when above the line leadership is better than below the line leadership

There are several situations when above the line leadership is better than below the line leadership:

  1. Above the line leadership is better when there is a clear goal that needs to be achieved
  2. Above the line leadership is better when there is a need for quick decision-making
  3. Above the line leadership is better when there is a need for coordination and cooperation among team members
  4. Above the line leadership is better when team members need to be motivated to achieve a common goal

Situations when below the line leadership is better than above the line leadership

There are certain situations when below the line leadership is more effective than above the line leadership:

  1. One such situation is when there is a need for quick decision-making. Below the line leaders are able to make decisions quickly as they are not bogged down by bureaucracy. This can be beneficial in emergency situations or when time is of the essence.
  2. When there is a need for flexibility. Below the line leaders are often more flexible and adaptable than their above the line counterparts. This can be beneficial in rapidly changing environments or when circumstances are constantly evolving.
  3. Below the line leadership can also be more effective in smaller organizations or teams. This is because below the line leaders are often more hands-on and have a better understanding of the day-to-day operations. This can lead to increased efficiency and effectiveness within the organization or team.
Above the line vs below the line leadership, explore the difference pin

Above the line vs below the line leadership summary

Above the line leadership is focused more on long-term goals and results while below the line leadership is focused more on short-term goals and immediate results. Both have their own pros and cons, so it’s important to choose what type of leader you want to be or what type of leader your organization needs depending on the situation. Thank you for reading this article! If you have any questions, please leave a comment below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top

GET A FREE CONSULTATION

Enter your contact details and I will get in touch!

OR

Send a Message. I will respond quickly!

100% FREE GUIDE!

Lead Your Life: 5 Steps To Master Everyday Leadership Skills

Get this guide in 2 easy step!!